Looking for the cheesy goodness that can only be found in the best pizza in Brooklyn?
If so then this ginormous list of the best pizza places in Brooklyn is 110% for you.
After all, I’m a 30+ year local who knows exactly where to go to swan dive into Brooklyn’s best pizza.
So, you’ll find no mediorce at best pizzerias on this list. Instead, you’ll enjoy culinary offerings from all the top pizzerias in Brooklyn.
In fact, you’ll have a hard time restraining yourself from devouring an entire pie all by yourself.
Therefore, stop fantasizing about mouth-wateringly delicious pizza and start enjoying the best pizza that this iconic borough has to offer.
This post may contain affiliate links. Please see my disclosure for more information. As an Amazon Associate, I earn a small commission from qualifying purchases.
⏰ Looking for a great budget place to stay in Brooklyn? Book the Aloft New York Brooklyn. Not only is it budget friendly, it has some swanky rooms! ⏰
Table of Contents
Where to Stay In Brooklyn
If you’re not sure where to spend the night in the glorious borough of Brooklyn, then check out this quick and easy insider’s guide to some of the best hotels in Brooklyn.
Aloft New York Brooklyn (Budget) – If you’re on a limited budget then Aloft New York Brooklyn is a great option.
After all, it’s near the Hoyt subway station and has well-appointed rooms with flat-screen TVs and walk-in showers. There’s also a rad rooftop bar and indoor pool for you to use too.
Hampton Inn Manhattan-Seaport-Financial District (Mid-range) – While technically not in Brooklyn, this amazing hotel is a chill place to stay with reasonably priced rooms that feature wifi, custom-designed beds, and flat-screen TVs.
Complimentary breakfast is also on offer as is access to an on-site gym.
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge (Luxury) – A swank five-star hotel that is conveniently located in Brooklyn Bridge Park and that has industrial-themed rooms with Nespresso machines, flat-screen TVs, and more.
Also, check out the gorg views from the rooftop bar before sampling decadent delights from their on-site eatery.
Best Pizza in Brooklyn – DUMBO
1. Grimaldi’s
Grimaldi’s is easily one of the most popular places to grab a pizza in the super-cool DUMBO neighborhood.
After all, their location, right next to the Brooklyn Bridge, is perfect for exploration of the beach at Brooklyn Bridge Park and for a quick ride on the Jane’s Carousel.
However, things get even cooler once you step inside. See, the open kitchen here means that you can watch your chosen pizza being prepped and tossed in the air for a quick spin before being flung into their iconic coal-burning ovens.
These bad boys are heated to scorching temperatures of up to 1,200 degrees to produce a devastatingly thin crust with a smoky finish.
Truth be told though, all pizzas at Grimaldi’s start their life with a fiercely guarded “secret” recipe that helps create the best pizza in Brooklyn.
And if you have the energy for it, you can even build your own pizza from scratch.
But, if you’ve got sights to see, you can speed things up and go straight to one of their signature pies.
In fact, oven-roasted red peppers, creamy ricotta, and hand-pinched Italian sausage perfectly combine to create the Brooklyn Bridge, aka their OG pizza.
Extra brownie points to this family-owned pizzeria for its commitment to charitable organizations and pro-bono efforts.
Pro Tip: This eatery is regularly packed since many people think this place has Brooklyn’s best pizza. So, expect a line and try to visit at an off-peak time to enjoy one of those places you must eat in NYC.
Address: 1 Front St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, United States
Hours: Open daily from 11:30 am to 10:00 pm.
Price: Pizzas typically cost between $9.50 and $17.50 each.
How to Get There: Take the A/C train to High Street station or the 2/3 train to Clark Street station and walk from there.
2. Juliana’s
Confession time. Despite just waxing lyrical about Grimaldi’s, there’s another option that I personally rank far higher as the best pizza in Brooklyn…at least in the DUMBO neighborhood that is.
In fact, Juliana’s is located next door to Grimaldi’s and was even started be members of the same family.
Apparently, acclaimed chef Patsy Grimaldi, umm, retired from his retirement in 2012 to open up version 2.0 of his imoortal pizza restaurant.
Employing the same techniques, Juliana’s is revered for its commitment to sourcing the freshest ingredients that provide guests with the best taste possible.
And while their pizza list is relatively compact, it perfectly encapsulates the finest Italian flavors.
So, order a “classic” and you can spruce it up with two addtional toppings of your choice. Easy does it though, when it comes to dining at Juliana’s.
Because their “number one” actually pulls together the simple yet rewarding tones of mozzarella, Scamorza affumicata, pancetta, and scallions.
I’ll put it out there that I think Grimaldi’s is slightly overrated but, hey, if you’re hanging around Brooklyn for longer than a weekend – eat at both places and drop a comment down below to let me know which one you prefer.
Address: 19 Old Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, United States
Hours: Open daily from 11:30 am to 3:15 pm and from 4:00 pm to 9:00 pm.
Price: Pizzas are between $14.00 and $25.00 each.
How to Get There: Take the A/C train to High Street station or the 2/3 train to Clark Street station and walk from there.
3. Ignazio’s
Third and final shout for the DUMBO area when it comes to the best pizza in Brooklyn. Because Ignazio’s dishes up delicious, paper-thin pizzas at the foot of the Brooklyn Bridge too.
The space itself though consists of a roomy interior and a newly-added outdoor dining area.
And the menu is fabulously varied to appease vegetarians and meat-eaters alike.
However, seafood aficionados will be in their element at Ignazio’s since their speciality list includes both a shrimp and white clam pie.
Plus, Ignazio’s is an ideal spot if you just want to order a slice.
Or, for those with a bigger appetite, split one of their tempting appetizers. I mean, meatballs cooked in tomato sauce with pecorino romano cheese and fresh basil is sire to warm your tummy up while you wait.
Plus, if you’re staying locally, you can order a home pizza kit delivered to your door and try your hand at pizza-making while enjoying the top pizza in Brooklyn.
Address: 4 Water St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, United States
Hours: Open daily from 12:00 pm to 8:30 pm.
Price: Whole pizzas start at $25.00 each.
How to Get There: Take the F train to York Street or the A/C train to High Street station and walk from there.
Best Pizza in Brooklyn – Williamsburg
4. Roberta’s
You’ll find Roberta’s off Flushing Avenue on the cusp of East Williamsburg and Bushwick.
Then, step inside to uncover edgy interiors and an atmospheric terrace complete with a tiki bar that make this one of the coolest places to eat the best pizza in Brooklyn.
Plus, the kitchen is open so you can watch your order come to life right bedore your eyes. The menu also includes a wide array of artisanal pizzas as well as pasta, grills, and shareable salumi.
If you only order one dish though, make it the Bee Sting Pizza. See, it has a simple base of tomato, mozzarella, and soppressata that is dressed up with a splash of chili, honey, and freshly cut basil.
Also, take advantage of their experimental cocktails while you’re here and order their frozen mezcal punch to put a spring back in your step.
Best of all, Roberta’s is a dog-friendly joint. Therefore, you might meet a couple of new furry friends while you chow down on your pizza of choice.
Address: 6 Grand St, Brooklyn, NY 11249, United States
Hours: Open daily from 12:00 pm to 10:00 pm, with extended hours until 11:00 pm on Friday and Saturday.
Price: Pizzas start at $16.00 each.
How to Get There: Take the L train to Bedford Avenue and walk from there.
5. Joe’s Pizza
Founded in 1975 by Joe Pozzuoli, a Neapolitan born and bred, Joe’s Pizza started life in Greenwich Village.
However, it didn’t take long for the family-style pizzeria to garner the interest of New Yorkers and passersbys from around the world.
Therfore, now, Joe’s Pizza has an equally awesome outpost on Bedford Avenue, in Williamsburg.
Combining Neapolitan and Big Apple techniques and toppings, Joe’s Pizza is the answer if you’re searching for that quintessential NY slice.
We’re talking crispy on the bottom with a lots of tomato sauce and a foldable crust with grease oozing out the bottom.
You’ll also love that that the best pizza in Brooklyn is served by either the slice or the pie.
Personally, I highly recommend the white pizza with spinach and garlic. It’s utterly divine and light enough to avoid that dreaded post-pizza slump.
Plus, snug interiors are adorned with shots of celebrities that have popped into Joe’s over the decades. You can also find a couple of extra seats out on the terrace or simply grab a slice to go.
Address: 216 Bedford Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11249, United States
Hours: Open daily from 10:30 am to 3:00 am.
Price: Pies start at $21.00 each.
How to Get There: Take the L train to Bedford Avenue and walk from there.
6. Motorino
This Broadway-based pizzeria is your one-stop shop for the best pizza in Brooklyn, Neapolitan-style.
You also love that Motorino occupies a super sleek dining space that includes exposed brick, whitewashed walls, and subway tiles that create a mellow setting.
Just be aware that many of the pizzas here contain anchovies. So, if you’re a fan, this might be the pizza spot for you.
Otherwise, vegans can dive into two of the best plant-based pizzas in New York. Therefore, let your nose be your guide as you chooce between white and red.
Next, enjoy toppings like vegan mozzarella and vegan sausage, either of which is offered as an extra topping elsewhere on the menu.
Also spare a thought for their starters before heading here since the roasted artichoke served with lemon, capers, and garlic might even surpass the pizza when it comes to deliciousness.
Pro Tip: Don’t want to come all the way to Brooklyn? Then you’ll be delighted to know that Motorino has two other locations in Manhattan. So, it’s know easier than ever to dig into the
Address: 139 Broadway, Brooklyn, NY 11211
Hours: Open daily from 12:00 pm to 10:30 pm.
Price: Pies start at $14.00 each.
How to Get There: Take the M or J train to Marcy Avenue and walk from there.
7. Emmy Squared
Emmy Squared specializes in Detroit-style pizza. So, slices are rectangular-shaped and come with a thick crust that is, somehow, magically crispy and chewy at the same time.
It’s madness I tell you! And I mean that in the best possible way.
Interiors are also light and hip since they features exposed brick walls and a stylish bar with additional seating.
Plus, their wholesome pies come prepared with your choice of red or white sauce. If you want, you can even build your own pie or stick to the menu.
It’s a little out there but the vodka pizza – made with Emmy Squared’s house vodka sauce topped with basil and pecorino – is a starting point for the brave.
Otherwise, go for the Emmy, crafted with banana peppers, red onion, and ranch. Whatever you do, scoop up a portion of cheesy garlic sticks to go on the side.
Also, be sure to visit Emmy Squared on the weekends so that you can enjoy the star of their brunch menu: the hangover pizza. See, pizza really is medicinal at one of the best brunch places in Brooklyn.
Pro Tip: All of the pizzas here can also be made with a gluten-free bases making this the best pizza in Brooklyn for GF diners.
Address: 364 Grand St, Brooklyn, NY 11211, United States
Hours: Open Monday through Wednesday from 5:00 pm to 9:00 pm, Thursday from 1:00 pm to 9:00 pm, and Friday/Saturday from 12:00 pm to 10:00 pm.
Price: Pizzas start at $18.00 each.
How to Get There: Take the L train to Bedford Avenue or the M train to Marcy Avenue and walk from there.
Best Pizza in Brooklyn – Carroll Gardens
8. F&F Pizzeria
F&F Pizzeria features a mouth-watering delicious menu filled with favlorful ingredients that form the basis of its New York-style pizza.
In fact, the dough at F&F deserves a special mention. Because chefs and co-owners, Frank Castronovo and Frank Falcinelli, drew from their extensive baking careers to create moreish sourdough and focaccia bases.
So, browse through the pizzas on the counter before ordering a slice to gobble up on the sidewalk. Or, if you can’t resist a full pie, grab a seat in the small outdoor dining area.
Yeah, there’s not a ton of space so aim to avoid the lunchtime rush.
In particuliar, The Partanna offers up delectable flavors of mozzarella, pecorino romano, Calabrian chili, Sicilian oregano, and orange blossom honey.
Therefore, this one sits up there at the top of the list for some of the best pizza in Brooklyn for vegetarians.
However, do this the right way and order a couple of slices so you can sample different types of pizza from across the menu.
Address: 459 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, United States
Hours: Open Wednesday through Sunday from 12:00 pm to 9:00 pm, with extended hours until 10:00 pm on Fridays and Saturdays.
Price: Pies start at $29.00 each.
How to Get There: Take the F or G train to Carroll Street and walk from there.
9. Lucali
If you’re after a more romantic spot for pizza in Brooklyn’s Carroll Gardens, take a jaunt around the block to Lucali.
This upmarket yet comfortably casual joint consists of homey interiors with a rustic finish and a small patio out back.
Pizza is also baked using a traditional brick oven to produce an authentic Italian taste. Plus, emphasis is placed on exquisite ingredients and sublimely hand-crafted dough.
Soi, when you dine here you basically have two choices. You can snap up the large pie with basil and stringy mozzarella and garnish as you wish from a boutique list of toppings.
Or, go big with the calzone. It’s simple yet solid with ricotta and a side of sauce for dipping. The dough is also sublimely soft, fluffy, and light with a satisfyingly crunchy exterior.
Sure, it comes in a smaller size, but you’ll regret not ordering the large while checking out the best pizza in Brooklyn.
Pro Tip: Lucali is cash-only (and BYOB) so come prepared.
Address: 575 Henry St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, United States
Hours: Open Wednesday through Monday from 5:00 pm to 11:00 pm.
Price: Between $11.00 and $30.00.
How to Get There: Take the F or G train to Carroll Street and walk from there.
Brooklyn’s Best Pizza – Bed-Stuy
10. Saraghina Pizzeria
Saraghina Pizzeria is a classy destination in Bed-Stuy for upmarket Neapolitan pizzas prepared in a wood-burner.
The interior dining space is also filled with ambient natural light that pours in through the skylights.
Although, the backyard with its leafy greens is where you’ll want to head on a warm afternoon to enjoy Brooklyn’s best pizza.
Now, Saraghina’s pizza menu celebrates the staples of Italian cooking. So, pies are generously adorned with the likes of buffalo milk mozzarella, Parmacotto ham, olives, and fragrant herbs.
In particuliar, The funghi and Tartufo pizza is prepared with a vibrant mixture of maitake and cremini mushrooms to create the ultimate veggie feast.
Plus, any of the pizzas on their meny can be made gluten-free or vegan upon request, for a small additonal fee.
And if you happen to be dining with non-pizza eaters, the menu here also offers a tantalizing spread of primi and secondi plates that are made using succulent Italian recipes.
Just be aware that Saraghina Pizzeria only accepts reservations for groups of 8+ people. Otherwise, this eatery operates on a first come, first served basis.
Address: 350 Lewis Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11233, United States
Hours: Open daily from 4:00 pm to 10:00 pm, except on Saturdays and Sundays when they open at 10:00 am.
Price: Pizzas start at $17.00 each.
How to Get There: Take the A/C train to Utica Avenue and walk from there.
Brooklyn’s Best Pizza – Coney Island
11. L&B Spumoni Gardens
This historic Coney Island (lower Bensonhurst) pizzeria has been on the scene since 1939. And that makes sense given Its commitment to excellent cuisine and unbeatable service.
Plus, it doesn’t here that L&B Spumoni Gardens is known for its Sicilian-style square pizzas.
In fact, the item to order is the World Famous L&B Sicilian Pie! So, order a slice or upgrade to the whole pie.
Because what’s unique about the cooking method here is that the cheese is actually placed beneath the sauce.
Next, add toppings to the thick base of the best pizza in Brooklyn, like extra cheese, pepperoni, and anchovies.
However, a smaller, round pie is also available alongside Italian fare including pasta, salads, and meat dishes.
Additionally, L&B Spumoni Gardens has ample seating to fit the entire family, with surplus space on the patio when the weather is nice.
Word of warning though. Don’t leave without ordering a scoop of gelato for dessert.
Address: 2725 86th St, Brooklyn, NY 11223, United States
Hours: Open daily from 11:00 am to 11:30 pm.
Price: Pizza slices start at $4.00 each.
How to Get There: Take the N train to 86th street or the D train to 25th Avenue and walk from there.
12. Surf City
Surf City Pizzeria Pasta Restaurant is another great option for the best pizza in Brooklyn – at least if you’re in Coney Island.
See, this family-centered joint has tables aplenty with outdoor seating available too. The vibe is also super laid-back, making this an easy place to go to after a long day at the beach.
Or, you can grab curbside pick-up and take it back down to the boardwalk for open-air dining.
If you want, they even have their own take on the Sicilian square and feature all your standard combos like veggie, meat, and fish.
Plus, with your kids in tow, you can ignite their creativity with a pizza base that’s fully customizable.
However, Italians, look away now, because their Hawaiin is the perfect ‘lil pick-me-up after a day on the sand.
Pro Tip: Take advanatge of Surf City’s generous all-day happy hour drinks.
Address: 837 Surf Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11224, United States
Hours: Open daily from 11:30 am to 10:00 pm.
Price: Pizzas start at $20.00 each.
How to Get There: Take the Q or the F train to the New York Aquarium station and walk from there.
13. Totonno’s
Totonno’s is quaint and quirky. Set up in an old school joint, Totonno’s provides thin crust coal oven pizzas. As can be imagined, this is one of the popular favorites for anyone who is visiting Coney island.
Totonno’s has the best pizza not just in New York but in America. Don’t take my word for it though. The food network has bestowed the award on this humble Brookly pizzeria so you know that it is really good.
Like Luigi’s Totonno’s is a family owned business and has been open for over 100 years. If you don’t know what to order, keep it simple. Try the margherita or the Bianca. These are two of the top favorites here.
Pro Tip: If the weather is good, take your pizza to the beach. You can’t beat the combination of good food and fresh air. If the weather isn’t great, you can choose to dine in.
Address: 1524 Neptune Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11224, United States
Hours: Thursday to Sunday: 12 – 8pm
How To Get There: Take the bus to W 17 St/Neptune Av and walk from there.
Brooklyn’s Best Pizza – Crown Heights
14. Barboncino Pizza
Barboncino Pizza is a friendly eatery specializing in Neapolitan pizzas prepared in a wood-burning oven for a satisfying crispy finish to your slice.
The place also has an electric atmosphere that makes it a top choice for a date, group, or special occasion among anyone looking for the best pizza in Brooklyn.
In fact, the owner and head chef, Ron Brown, is a self-confessed pizza enthusiast who spent six summers learning the fine art of pizza-making in Italy.
And when he’s not plotting out his next menu, he writes and directs independent films.
In fact, he even employs an eclectic assortment of staff memebrs from the arts and creative world who add to the unique ethos of this exciting place!
You’ll also find pizzas neatly spread across red and white varieties. And setting out to show that it’s all about quality over quantity, the arugula is a firm favorite.
Over on the red side though, the eggplant and zucchini pie really stands out. But, in honesty, every dish is a winner at Barboncino.
Then, wash down your pizza choice with one of their potent cocktails which come in a wealth of hot and cold infusions.
Address: 781 Franklin Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238, United States
Hours: Open daily from 11:00 am to 11:00 pm.
Price: Pizzas start at $14.00 each.
How to Get There: Take the 2/3/4 train to Franklin Avenue/Medgar Evers College station and walk from there.
Brooklyn’s Best Pizza – Brooklyn Heights
15. Dellarocco’s Brick Oven Pizza
Right around the block from Brooklyn Bridge Park, Dellarocco’s Brick Oven Pizza is handily located for some post-walk grub.
And some of the best pizza in Brooklyn Heights is served the traditional Neapolitan way, using a wood-fired brick oven to produce a crispy base.
Next, choose between red and white varieties that are fully loaded with rustic toppings and a generous mixture of either meat-based or vegetarian options.
So, opt for the Arrabbiata if you can handle the heat. Otherwise, you can never go wrong with their trademark Dellarocco.
It fatures a base of smoked buffalo mozzarella cheese and broccoli that is seasoned with red pepper flakes, Italian sweet sausage, garlic, and basil.
Pair this with the crostini appetizer – a slider of four bruschetta – that you can nibble on while you wait for the best pizza in Brooklyn to be made from scratch.
You’ll also love the actual restaurant since it is a bright, airy, and modern space that nods toward European design, coomplete with a bar as its centerpiece.
Address: 214 Hicks St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, United States
Hours: Open daily from 12:00 pm to 10:00 pm, with extended hours until 10:30 pm on Friday and Saturday.
Price: Pies start at $11.00 each.
How to Get There: Take the 2/3 to Clark Street or the R train to Court Street and walk from there.
16. Table 87
Table 87 fuses together the best of Italian and North American pizza heritage using their coal oven
Founded by Tommy Cucco, Table 87 now operates three brick-and-mortar locations in Brooklyn alone.
Yup, the other two outposts can be found in Gowanus and Industry City respectively. But, Brooklyn Heights is their flagship location and a must-see if you’re looking for the best pizza in Brooklyn.
Yes, space is limited. But, if you can score a table, the bustling brickwork dining area features a fantastic atmosphere.
Plus, nobody will ever leave Table 87 disappointed by their signature, finely-tuned margherita pizza.
Although, an upgrade to the burrata margherita is a total blast for the taste buds!
And besides the regular pizzas, Table 87 is one of the best places to eat a calzone in Brooklyn.
Address: 87 Atlantic Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11201, United States
Hours: Open daily from 11:00 am to 10:00 pm.
Price: Pizzas start at $13.00 each.
How to Get There: Take the 2/3 train to Clark Street or the R train to Court Street and walk from there.
Best Pizza in Brooklyn – Clinton Hill
17. Emily
Emily is a gourmet pizza place in Clinton Hill that also features a second outpost in the West Village.
In fact, this mini-franchise has a couple at the helm whose early romance was kindled by a shared passion for pizza.
Therefore, red, white, and pink pizzas dominate the menu, along with an expertly curated selection of other dishes too.
But, wait, What constitutes pink pizza? Well, pink pizzas are created using a homemade vodka-based sauce.
And if you’re not sure what to order, The Big Ang will speak to carnivores while the Famous Original Dan will satiate any veggies out there.
But, across the menu you’ll find lots of pizza staples like garlic, herbs, and Italian cheeses/sausages.
So, Emily is a chill spot for a quick lunch. Although, the ambiance is top-notch in the evening when music and candles both help set the mood.
Plus, this is one of the few pizza places in Brooklyn that accepts reservations for couples and small groups.
Address: 919 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11238, United States
Hours: Open daily from 5:00 pm to 9:00 pm, with additional hours from 12:00 to 3:30 pm on Saturday and Sunday.
Price: Pizzas start at $17.00 each.
How to Get There: Take the A/C to Clinton and Washington Avenue station and walk from there.
18. Speedy Romeo
Speedy Romeo was named in honor of the co-owner Todd Feldman’s family champion racehorse. So, look out for the portrait of Speedy Romeo’s himself hanging in the bar.
This pizza place is also set inside a former bar turned liquor store turned auto parts shop in Clinton Hill.
Therefore, interiors retain a gritty yet charming vibe while the facade pays homage to the restaurant’s previous life and history.
In terms of the food, pizzas are cooked in a hardwood fired Italian pizza oven with other plates going on a wood grill from Mesquite, Texas.
Now, if you’re super hungry, order a calzone. After all, The Speedy Romeo calzone is stuffed with ricotta, smoked mozzarella, and mushrooms – making it a veggie-friendly pick.
Abnd while the pizza list is humble, they are all delicious and come with the option to further customize with additional toppings.
Plus, there are a couple of options for vegans, making Speedy Romeo a contender for one of the best pizza places in Brooklyn for plant-based eaters.
Otherwise, Mike’s Brocollini is worth it for the chance to taste Mike’s Hot Honey.
Address: 376 Classon Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238, United States
Hours: Open daily from 11:00 am to 10:00 pm, with extended hours until 11:00 pm on Friday and Saturday and reduced hours until 9:00 pm on Sunday.
Price: Pizzas start at $17.00 each.
How to Get There: Take the G train to Classon Avenue and walk from there.
Brooklyn’s Best Pizza – Midwood
19. Di Fara Pizza
Expect a line at Di Fara Pizza, one of the most iconic pizza haunts in NYC.
FYI, a line in NYC is never a bad thing: it means that the Brooklynites (and even, according to rumor, Manhattanites) approve.
Now, Di Fara established its kitchen and counter in 1964 after Domenico “Dom” De Marco uprooted from the Province of Caserta and settled in Brooklyn.
As a result, pizza is served by the slice or by the pie as regular or square. And it’s a relatively simple affair with a margherita base and the option to add toppings of your choosing.
Now, I know you might give pause at the thought of schlepping all the way to Midwood since it’s not exactly on the tourist trail.
But – if you want to sample some of the best pizza in Brooklyn – the bus ride out is worth it. And you can even consider this field trip one of the more unique things to do in NYC.
Pro Tip: There’s not a ton of seating here. So, plan to eat your slice the old-school way.
Address: 1424 Avenue J, Brooklyn, NY 11230, United States
Hours: Open daily from 12:00 pm to 8:00 pm, except they are closed on Mondays.
Price: A regular slice starts at $5.00.
How to Get There: Take the Q train to Avenue J and walk from there.
Best Pizza in Brooklyn – Greenpoint
20. Paulie Gee’s
Paulie Gee’s crafts some of the best pizza in Brooklyn in terms of kooky ingredients that you rarely see on a pie.
Yeah, we’re talking sake, lemon juice, and chili honey.
Their unusual pizzas are then paired with a unique dining room that feels more like a midwest saloon than an NYC pizza joint.
Paulie Gee’s has also outdone itself in terms of its commitment to creating vegan pizzas. So, the lengthy menu here is packed with vegan substitutes generously topped with tasty veggies and herbs.
This restaurant also deserves a slow clap for their plant-based desserts too, options that include apple pie and a vegan chocolate brownie.
You can also swing by Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop, which is just a block away and is sure to give you your lunchtime pizza fix.
Address: 60 Greenpoint Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222, United States
Hours: Open daily from 6:00 pm to 10:00 pm, with extended hours until 11:00 pm on Friday and Saturday.
Price: Pizzas start at $16.00 each.
How to Get There: Take the G to Greenpoint Avenue and walk from there.
Brooklyn’s Best Pizza – Sunset Park
21. Giuseppina’s
Convenient for a post Prospect Park hiking sesh, Giuseppina’s is one of the best pizza restaurants in Brooklyn for a calzone.
Because in addition to the staple savory calzone – crammed with mozzarella, ricotta, and fresh grated Reggiano Pecorino cheese – there’s also a Nutella one for dessert.
In fact, this sweet variation contains a beautiful mix of honey ricotta and is topped with powdered sugar and sea salt to produce an explosive taste sensation.
Elsewhere, the pizza menu is short and sweet with a choice of a red, a white, a “everything”, or a Giuseppina special.
The latter two are pretty pricey but they are beautifully presented and the kitchen team certainly does not scrimp on the quantity of the toppings.
They also have a tempting selection of wines to pair with your chosen pie.
The restaurant itself occupies a retro space in Sunset Park that offers snug indoor seating and a scattering of seasonal tables on the terrace.
Additionally, this is a cash-only restaurant so remember to stock your wallet with lots of Benjamins before you arrive to enjoy the best pizza in Brooklyn.
Address: 691 6th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, United States
Hours: Open daily from 5:00 pm to 10:30 pm and closed on Tuesdays.
Price: Pizzas start at $26.00 each.
How to Get There: Take the D or R train to Prospect Avenue and walk from there.
22. Luigi’s Pizza
Luigi’s Pizza is insanely popular. The incredible pizzas that they serve have not changed much over the years. Odds are you will be served up a slice of paradise by the chef itself. It honestly is really cool because it adds that extra personal touch. Plus, you get to talk to a living legend!
The pizzeria is so popular that it was featured in Big Daddy. Yes. I’m talking about the classic movie that featured Adam Sandler. Obviously after it got featured, its rise to fame was phenomenal.
Despite the fact that Luigi’s Pizza is so popular, this family based restaurant hasn’t raised its rates like many of the places around. This makes the pizza pretty affordable and honestly the chef really delivers when it comes to the taste!
Pro Tip: Luigi’s does not offer indoor dining. It only offers delivery or takeaway so don’t head here expecting a sit down meal. You can however take the pizza to a nearby park and enjoy it on a sunny day.
Address: 686 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, United States
Hours: Monday to Saturday: 11am – 9:30pm
How To Get There: Prospect Av Subway station is the closest to Luigi’s pizza. It is a short walk away.
Best Pizza in Brooklyn FAQ
Why Is Brooklyn Famous For Pizza?
Brooklyn has some of the best pizza in NYC and its story isn’t new. Way back in the mid 20th century, the borough was introduced to the signature pies of popular joints like L&B Spumoni Gardens.
Obviously once the people tasted these amazing pizzas, they were addicted. Eventually the art spread out to other spots and numerous pizzerias popped up across Brooklyn.
If you haven’t tasted the pizzas here yet, make sure that you rectify the mistake and visit one of the best pizza joints in Brooklyn!
What Is New York’s Famous Pizza?
New York’s pizza is famous across the world. The pizza crust is the key difference when it comes to other locations across the USA. Made by hand, the crust is thin and the pizzas are large.
One of the best things about New York pizza is the thick rim of crust around the pizza. It isn’t doughy though. The edge is crisp. Don’t ask me how they do it BUT trust me! It is delicious!
Obviously the pizza still comes in the same number of slices which means that the slices are wide. It’s a large slice of deliciousness!
Oh and if you want to look like a local, make sure not to fold it down the middle. Yeah! We don’t do that in NYC!
Why Is It Called New York Style Pizza?
Did you know that there are loads of Italian immigrants in New York? Way back in the 1900s, these immigrants brought pizza to the shores of NYC. The Neapolitan style pizza evolved to the thin based, thick rimmed, larged sliced pizza that we know and love!
The best part about the evolution of the New York style pizza is its crispy crust. You have to taste it to know exactly what I mean!
⏰ Looking for a great budget place to stay in Brooklyn? Book the Aloft New York Brooklyn. Not only is it budget friendly, it has some swanky rooms! ⏰
Map of the Best Pizza in Brooklyn
Additional Brooklyn Resources You’ll Love
There you have it! That just about wraps up this guide to the best pizza in Brooklyn.
Tell me, did your choice for Brooklyn’s best pizza make the list? If not then let me know below.
And if you found this post useful, be sure to join our email list before pinning this post now so that you can read it again later.
