On a budget but still wanna look like a total badass while strutting down the streets of NYC’s hippest borough? If so then check out this extra snazzy list of the best thrift stores in Brooklyn.
Trust me, I’ve lived in the area for 30+ years. Therefore, I know exactly where to go if you want to do a bit of bargain hunting but don’t want to look more than a little homeless.
Yeah, there’s nothing worse than going bargain hunting at some of the best thrift shops in Brooklyn and then looking like you’ve been impromptu dumpster diving, not shopping.
So, if you want to look and feel like Carrie Bradshaw but have the budget of one of the main characters from Girls, then this list of the best vintage stores Brooklyn has to offer is where it’s at.
After all, this mega list will help you quickly and easily find all the places where locals really go to look fly like a G-6 while walking down the streets of the Big Apple.
This post may contain affiliate links. Please see my disclosure for more information. As an Amazon Associate, I earn a small commission from qualifying purchases.
⏰ In a hurry and wondering where to stay in Brooklyn? I highly recommend the Hampton Inn Manhattan-Seaport-Financial District. It is a midrange hotel with great views and all the luxury you could need! 🏨
Table of Contents
Where to Stay in Brooklyn
Not sure where to stay while checking out some of the best thrift stores in Brooklyn? If so then have a look at this down-and-dirty guide to my fave places to stay in the ever-hip Brooklyn.
And don’t worry because even if you have a tiny budget there is still a ton of great places for you to stay in Brooklyn.
Aloft New York Brooklyn (Budget)
⭐️ Rating: 6/10 (901 Reviews) Price: $262 per night 📍Location: 216 Duffield Street, Downtown Brooklyn, Brooklyn, NY Details: Read more on booking.com now!
Easily one of the best budget hotels in Brooklyn, a room at Aloft New York Brooklyn will feel fancy but won’t cost you an arm and a leg. You’ll also be well-located near the subway and can relax inside rooms with flat-screen TVs, ergonomic chairs, and walk-in showers. There’s even a great indoor pool and rooftop bar for you to check out too.
Hampton Inn Manhattan-Seaport-Financial District (Mid-range)
⭐️ Rating: 7.9/10 (1,297 Reviews) Price: $269 per night 📍Location: 320 Pearl Street, Wall Street – Financial District, New York, NY Details: Read more on booking.com now!
Technically, this Hampton Inn sits over the river in Manhattan. But, the views are great and the rooms start at around $100 per night. They also all come with custom-designed beds, Wifi, flat-screen TVs, and complimentary, made-to-order breakfast daily.
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge (Luxury)
⭐️ Rating: 8.2/10 (652 Reviews) Price: $538 per night 📍Location: 60 Furman Street, Brooklyn, NY Details: Read more on booking.com now!
The high life never looked better at this posh five-star hotel that can be found within Brooklyn Bridge Park. So, expect stellar views of the East River in addition to industrial-chic rooms with Nespresso machines and flat-screen TVs. There’s also a rooftop bar and a great restaurant on-site too.
Best Thrift Stores in Brooklyn – Park Slope
1. Housing Works Thrift Store
Starting this guide with a golden oldie, Housing Works Thrift Store is a one-stop shop for pre-loved clothing, jewelry, accessories, homeware, and more.
So, super perfect if you want to spend the day shopping for your birthday in NYC.
Plus, the high quality of the items here is superior to many of the other stores on this list of the best thrift stores in Brooklyn.
This store is also beautifully organized for stress-free browsing. Additionally, the stock is regularly replenished by generous locals, making it easy to uncover new treasures with every visit.
Housing Works is also one of the best thrift shops in Brooklyn for shoppers with a social-conscious.
Because this small cluster of thrift stores uses its profits to support homeless and low-income New Yorkers living with HIV/AIDS – as well as those in high-risk categories.
Therefore, you can spend time at one of the best places to shop in NYC on a budget knowing that your dollars will be used for a great cause.
Plus, in addition to Park Slope, you’ll find a Housing Works outpost in Brooklyn Heights and several others across the river in Manhattan. Heck, they even have a dedicated bookstore too.
Address: 266 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, United States
Hours: Open daily from 12:00 pm to 7:00 pm.
How to Get There: Take the N to Union Street and walk from there.
2. Life Boutique Thrift
Life Boutique Thrift has not one but two stores in Park Slope. So, pin 515 5th Ave and 66 5th Ave to your Google Maps so that you can scout out both as you enjoy some of the best thrift stores in Brooklyn.
And what makes this place extra special is that this not-for-profit duo of thrift stores donates all proceeds to Chai Lifeline.
They, in turn, provide support to children diagnosed with life-threatening illnesses and chronic conditions.
So, as with Housing Works, that’s a solid incentive to hit the shops.
And while secondhand and vintage clothing takes priority, you can also rummage around for homeware, accessories, jewelry, and antiques.
Clothing is also rotated out seasonally with Life Boutique Thrift selling off end-of-season stock with attractive deals and discounts.
Also, the stock here veers to the eclectic side. So, it’s one of the top thrift shops in Brooklyn for kooky fashionistas with playful style when it comes to clothing.
Address: 515 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, United States
Hours: Open Sunday through Friday from 11:00 am to 7:00 pm, closing early at 5:00 pm on Fridays.
How to Get There: Take the D or F train to 9th Street and walk from there.
3. m.a.e. Brooklyn
Easily one of the best consignment shops in Brooklyn, m.a.e. Brooklyn is a great choice if you’re looking for super high-end clothes at a deeply discounted price.
Yeah, it’s just a beautifully curated spot that I personally go to every time I want to buy something fancy.
In fact, I personally found several dresses and at least two pairs of awesome shoes during my last visit as I looked through their wealth of clothes, accessories, shoes, and more.
And added bonus? They even host private shopping events!
So, if a friend is celebrating a birthday in NYC then you can your bring them over and this thrift store in Brooklyn will supply the Champagne, balloons, and more!
Local Tip: This place is not for anyone shopping on a budget. This is one of the best thrift stores in Brooklyn for you if you are looking for Manolo Blahniks and Louboutins and discounted prices.
Address: 362 7th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215
Hours: Open Tuesday through Saturday from 12:00 pm to 7:00 pm and Sunday from 12:00 pm to 6:00 pm.
How to Get There: Take the D/N/R/W to 9th Street and walk from there.
Best Thrift Shops in Brooklyn – Williamsburg
4. The Attic Brooklyn, NY
The Attic Brooklyn, NY is one of the coolest thrift stores in Brooklyn for some seriously good threads and some great prices to boot.
Firstly, the space itself is a joy to stroll around in since it’s light and airy, without being cluttered. Items are also presented per garment AND color-coded.
Therefore, it feels more akin to a designer boutique than a low-budget thrift shop.
After all, the founders established this thrift store as a place where everyday people could go for fast fashion.
As a result, they’re committed to keeping prices as low as possible. This also means that you can walk away with some golden finds at a price point that doesn’t require a second mortgage on your home.
So what’s on the rack?
Well, collections here at one of the best thrift stores in Brooklyn reflect the seasons. However, you can look forward to shuffling through loud prints, vibrant colors, and meshed skirts à la Carrie Bradshaw.
There are even sleek leather jackets, chunky knits, and band t-shirts with just the right amount of sparkle and sequins just waiting to be purchased by any uber-trendy folks out there.
Address: 231 Grand St, Brooklyn, NY 11211, United States
Hours: Open daily from 11:00 am to 8:00 pm.
How to Get There: Take the L train to Bedford Avenue and walk from there.
5. Monk Vintage
Monk Vintage is stacked from floor to ceiling with awesome vintage ware that comes in all shapes, sizes, colors, and styles.
As a result, this is one of the best thrift shops in Brooklyn for big names. So, designers carried here include all the greats.
Therefore, Prada, check. Chanel, check. Gucci, check.
And if you have something specific in mind – style-wise or in terms of label – don’t be afraid to ask for help. After all, cheerful store associates are ready and willing to share their wisdom with you at a moment’s notice.
Plus, in addition to pre-worn apparel, Monk Vintage also sources merchandise that will appeal to a mix of metalheads, punk rockers, and pop princesses alike.
Just be aware that prices at Monk Vintage vary fairly dramatically and items are priced as per the label and the quality.
But, if you’re cunning and a super dedicated shopper, you can find some absolute steals here.
However, a word of warning. The interiors at one of the best thrift shops in Brooklyn are pretty jam-packed.
So, there is a lot of merch to peruse through. As a result, this place is recommended for hardcore thrift store shoppers with a whole lot of patience.
Address: 500 Driggs Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11211, United States
Hours: Open Monday through Thursday from 11:30 am to 7:45 pm, Friday/Saturday from 11:30 am to 8:15 pm, and Sunday from 12:00 pm to 7:45 pm.
How to Get There: Take the L train to Bedford Avenue and walk from there.
6. Buffalo Exchange
Buffalo Exchange is a nationwide franchise with around 40 locations scattered across the US.
And the name of the game here is resale fashion since they buy, trade, and sell contemporary apparel.
So, alongside a small batch of vintage pieces, you’ll be able to snap up on-trend fashion and designer labels from major brands.
This means that shopping at Buffalo Exchange is a much more sustainable way to update your closet with fast fashion and on-style trends.
And while most of the pieces are pre-owned, you’ll spot the occasional original tag ala accidental purchases or unwanted gifts.
Plus, since its conception in 1974, Buffalo Exchange has donated over 2 million dollars to charities and non-profits.
Therefore, step inside one of the best thrift stores in Brooklyn and enjoy a guilt-free shopping spree.
Pro Tip: Besides the Williamsburg location, you can also find Buffalo Exchange branches in Boerum Hill, Manhattan, and Queens.
Address: 504 Driggs Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11211, United States
Hours: Open daily from 11:00 am to 8:00 pm, closing early on Sundays at 7:00 pm.
How to Get There: Take the L train to Bedford Avenue and walk from there.
7. Brooklyn Woke Vintage
Roll up your sleeves and dive into one of the best thrift shops in Brooklyn for nostalgic souls.
Because Brooklyn Woke Vintage is a cornucopia of all things cute, cool, colorful, retro, and one-of-a-kind.
I mean, there’s so much more than clothing at this shopper’s wonderland since stock includes vintage baseballs and other sports gear in addition to plushies, dreamcatchers, and license plates.
You’ll also find a banging selection of refurbished Polaroid cameras, vinyl, comics, and cassettes (yes, it’s that old-school) on offer here.
Plus, Brooklyn Woke Vintage even stocks classic NYC souvenirs such as yellow cabs (mini ones, mind), patches, and novelty socks.
Although, it has to be said that clothing is a little thin on the ground. But, you’ll still find a couple of racks of quirky dresses, band tees, well-worn denim jackets, and baseball caps.
Plus, Brooklyn Woke Vintage has its very own line of merch that includes snazzy things like ultra-rad hoodies.
Because, yes, this is one of the best thrift shops in Brooklyn that really is that much of an institution.
Address: 158 Bedford Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11249, United States
Hours: Open daily from 10:00 am to 9:00 pm.
How to Get There: Take the L train to Bedford Avenue and walk from there.
8. Plus BKLYN
Plus BKLYN prides itself on being NYC’s premier boutique for plus-size clothes that “don’t suck”.
So, clothing sold here includes plus-size vintage, reworked vintage, resale pieces, and new styles.
And that makes sense since the motto at Plus BKLYN is that the bolder and brighter the better.
So, warm up with a look through their wide range of reworked 90s sweatshirts. Then, go full steam ahead by exmaning their impressive collection of florals, sequins, tropical, leopard print, and so forth.
Chipper staff are also welcoming and on hand to provide styling tips and advice.
You’ll also love that BKLYN is one of the best thrift shops in Brooklyn to remember once your trip to the city is over.
Because in addition to their epic bricks-and-mortar store, you can also shop online via their website and social media channels.
Also – Plus BKLYN will is super generous and will give you money in exchange for any old clothing you’re ready to part ways with.
Address: 490 Metropolitan Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11211, United States
Hours: Open daily from 12:00 pm to 8:00 pm.
How to Get There: Take the L train to Lorimer Street and walk from there.
9. 10 Ft. Single by Stella Dallas
With the emphasis firmly on clothes, 10 Ft. Single by Stella Dallas is a haven for dedicated vintage wearers looking for one of the best thrift stores in Brooklyn.
And while this isn’t the cheapest place to shop thrift-style in Brooklyn, that’s due to the quality of the pieces here.
So, if you’ve got a slightly larger budget for thrifting and are looking to invest in some knockout pieces, then this store is the one for you.
After all, 10 Ft. Single by Stella Dallas is packed to the rafters with womenswear, menswear, footwear, and accessories that any shopper out there will adore.
So, expect to find Converse sneakers in a kaleidoscope of hues as well as cowboy shirts, letterman jackets, fedora hats, and retro swimwear.
The store is also well laid out which makes for breezy shopping without feeling closed in. Just don’t leave without popping your head into the backroom for the crème de la crème of what this store has to offer.
Address: 285 N 6th St, Brooklyn, NY 11211, United States
Hours: Open daily from 12:00 pm to 7:15 pm.
How to Get There: Take the L train to Lorimer Street and walk from there.
10. Crossroads Trading Co.
Crossroads Trading Co. is a generously sized store in the buzzing Williamsburg neighborhood with a gigantic variety of clothing to rifle through.
But, luckily for you, racks here are laid out per garment, with plenty of space around them to avoid a bout of claustrophobia as you look through clearly priced pieces.
In a similar vein to the Buffalo Exchange, Crossroads Trading Co. operates a sustainable model of buying, trading, and selling.
Therefore, expect to find a mix of high street clothing, designer labels, and the odd vintage piece at one of the best thrift stores in Brooklyn.
However, the vast majority of items on offer are womenswear, with a decent selection of footwear and accessories too.
That’s what, Crossroads Trading Co. is easily one of the top thrift shops in Brooklyn for bargain hunters.
Pro Tip: You can also find a second store across the river in Manhattan.
Address: 135 N 7th St, Brooklyn, NY 11249, United States
Hours: Open daily from 11:00 am to 7:00 pm.
How to Get There: Take the L train to Bedford Avenue and walk from there.
11. Grand Street Local
Grand Street Local is a fun store with an expertly-curated selection of vintage wear for women and men.
So, items here hone in on styles from the 1940s through the 1990s. However, the emphasis here falls on the latter decades and classic American trends.
Therefore, you’ll find a treasure trove full of band, pop culture, sports, motorcycle t-shirts, and sweatshirts.
They also have an epic range of vintage clothes for kids. Therefore, if you’ve got little ones in tow (or want to claim the title of the world’s best aunt), this might be the best Brooklyn thrift store for you.
You’ll also love that Grand Street Local is kookily adorned with 90s merch that is neatly laid out to make shopping a breeze.
And because the store is owned by a young family, they know the stock inside out and will go above and beyond to match you with your dream tee of choice.
Address: 154 Grand St, Brooklyn, NY 11249, United States
Hours: Open Tuesday through Sunday from 12:00 pm to 6:00 pm.
How to Get There: Take the L train to Bedford Avenue and walk from there.
Best Thrift Stores in Brooklyn – DUMBO
12. Brooklyn Flea
Brooklyn Flea is easily NYC’s most famous flea market.
As a result, this weekly market occurs on weekends from April through December.
It also sees close to 100 vendors take to the streets of DUMBO to flog vintage fashion, unique antiques, fabulous furniture, and much (much) more.
So, as a visitor, this is easily one of the coolest places to prowl for souvenirs that you won’t be able to find anywhere else in the city.
You’ll also get to soak up the hipster chic atmosphere of DUMBO since Brooklyn Flea operates in a scenic spot beneath the Manhattan Bridge.
Accordingly, you will get to experience the thrill of shopping in NYC with an Instagrammable architectural icon as your backdrop.
And for any Brooklynites out there, this is one of the edgiest spots for items to deck out your loft. You can even refresh your wardrobe, or tackle your holiday shopping for the year.
Plus, alongside the wide array of wearables, you’ll no doubt find yourself swayed by the cuisine here since gourmet food stalls showcase the very best of Brooklyn’s artisanal food scene.
Therefore, be sure to roll on up with tote bags aplenty, and a giant appetite to match.
Pro Tip: Brooklyn Flea is unbeatable during the warmer months when you can grab a seat in the sunshine and indulge in some people-watching.
Address: 80 Pearl St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, United States
Hours: Open seasonally on weekends from 10:00 am to 5:00 pm.
How to Get There: Take the F train to York Street and walk from there.
Best Thrift Shops in Brooklyn – Bushwick
13. L Train Vintage
L Train Vintage is one cog in an NYC-based chain of thrift stores that also includes No Relation Vintage, Village Style, and Vice Versa Vintage.
See, this family-owned business initially arrived on the scene in 1999 and has since boomed into a mighty in-store and online retail venture.
So, if one of the best thrift shops in Brooklyn steals your heart, you can continue shopping with them long after your vacation ends.
L Train Vintage also sells just about anything that falls loosely within this category. As long as it’s hip. So, yeah, there’s nothing overly fussy about the stock here.
Additionally, you’ll find a buoyant offering of pop culture and band tees alongside retro basketball jerseys, checked shirts, and designer denim wear.
So, do not expect to leave one of the best thrift shops in Brooklyn empty-handed.
Plus, there are a couple of L Train Vintage stores dotted around Brooklyn. Therefore, you can take your pick from Bushwick, Williamsburg, Prospect Heights, and Boerum Hill locations.
Address: 1377 DeKalb Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11221, United States
Hours: Open daily from 12:00 pm to 7:00 pm, except they are closed Sundays.
How to Get There: Take the L train to DeKalb Avenue and walk from there.
14. Broadway Fashion
Bushwick’s Broadway Fashion is an Aladdin’s Cave of new vintage, designer, and popular fashion wear.
Therefore, items sold on-site are a mix of new and pre-loved pieces. Accordingly, expect to find household names and top-of-the-line designers including Gucci, Hugo Boss, and Louis Vuitton on the racks.
You’ll also need some time and patience since this store is chock full of clothing and you won’t want to leave a single hanger untouched.
However, you’ll be rewarded for your efforts since prices at Broadway Fashion are unbelievably reasonable.
Therefore, you’ll get a whole lot of bang for your buck. I mean, with $50 you could easily walk out with an entirely new wardrobe for the upcoming season.
Now, besides copious amounts of clothing, Broadway Fashion has an impressive line-up of footwear and accessories to complete your favorite Brooklyn-chic look.
Address: 1227 Broadway, Brooklyn, NY 11221, United States
Hours: Open daily from 10:00 am to 6:00 pm.
How to Get There: Take the J train to Kosciuszko Street station and walk from there.
15. New Brooklyn Fashion
Walk a couple of blocks up the road from Broadway Fashion and you’ll stumble upon yet another of the best thrift shops in Brooklyn for budget shoppers.
See, New Brooklyn Fashion (which may or may not be a distant cousin of its neighbor) is another treasure trove full of secondhand clothing.
In fact, there’s no shortage of options here, allowing you to easily walk away with an armful of bargain buys.
Now, the collection at New Brooklyn Fashion caters to eclectic shoppers with patience. As a result, you’ll find a diversity of sizes with the odd huge name hidden among the packed shelves.
In fact, recent successes have yielded a vintage 1980s Calvin Klein sweater and Lagerfeld dresses.
You’ll also love that items are priced exceedingly well and reflect the level of wear that each garment has undergone.
Yup, perfect for anyone who can’t resist a designer name but lacks the funds.
Address: 1065 Broadway, Brooklyn, NY 11221, United States
Hours: Open daily from 11:00 am to 8:30 pm, except on Sundays when they close at 8:00 pm.
How to Get There: Take the J train to Myrtle Avenue and walk from there.
16. Le Point Value
Le Point Value is a small-budget clothing chain for the entire family that has outposts in both Brooklyn and the Bronx.
However, I’ve earmarked Bushwick here since this neighborhood actually contains two outposts within walking distance of one another.
But, if you like what you see, definitely do a loop of the rest in other parts of the city.
Now, Le Point Value pitches itself as a family-friendly shopping spot with clothing for women, men, and children.
And despite the humble storefront, these stores present a secret stockpile of epic proportions that never seems to end.
So, panic-prone shoppers can rest easy because everything here is neatly divided by garment. Plus, the staff are great at keeping the premises in top shape so that everything is easy to find.
In particular, brands here veer towards popular brand names rather than designer or vintage.
However, the stock does vary radically and what you find at one of the best vintage stores Brooklyn has to offer really just depends on the day.
All in all, the Le Point Value thrift stores are the perfect destination for anyone with a hunger for a great deal. Especially if you’re itching to revamp your entire wardrobe on a shoestring.
Address: 1081 Flushing Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11237, United States
Hours: Open daily from 10:00 am to 5:30 pm.
How to Get There: Take the L train to Morgan Avenue and walk from there.
17. Green Village Used Furniture and Clothing
Green Village Used Furniture and Clothing has been on the Brooklyn thrift scene for what feels like eons.
As a result, his is your quintessential hub for just about any obscure ornament or bizarre trinket you can think of. And then things that you won’t believe actually exist.
Plus, this is one of the best thrift stores in Brooklyn that also sells genuinely useful things like toolbox staples, sports equipment, and stationery.
So, expect to find this warehouse piled high with vintage apparel and clothing that you can buy by the pound.
You’ll also see old-world furniture rubbing shoulders with the best of IKEA while classic camcorders mingle with mountains of books. It’s basically time travel for shoppers at one of the best thrift shops in Brooklyn.
So, if you want to give your closet a makeover, visit Green Village.
And if you want some new gear for your home office? Go to Green Village.
What? Need souvenirs for your nearest and dearest back home? Yup, Green Village has got you covered.
Yeah, this place is worth visiting purely for the nostalgia factor and the electric atmosphere of one of the best thrift shops in Brooklyn for unique buys.
Address: 276 Starr St, Brooklyn, NY 11237, United States
Hours: Open Sunday through Thursday from 12:00 pm to 6:00 pm.
How to Get There: Take the L train to Jefferson Street and walk from there.
18. The Salvation Army Brooklyn Bushwick Corps Community Center
Look, we all know about the Salvation Army for a reason. I mean, they have epic deals and are a great place to go if you’re short on cash and are looking for one of the best thrift stores in Brooklyn.
No, they aren’t one of the mega-cool independent vintage stores in Brooklyn.
But, the Salvation Army is an epic choice if you want to shop in a well-maintained space that has a ton of merch to choose from – clothes that are spread out across many different levels.
Therefore, it’s easy to shop for cool stuff since you have tons of space and can enjoy this wonderfully clean store.
Yes, you’ll really have to dig to find any designer threads at one of the best thrift stores Brooklyn has to offer. But, isn’t that all part of the fun. Come on, you know it is.
Address: 1151 Bushwick Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11221
Hours: Open Monday through Friday from 9:00 am to 5:00 pm.
How to Get There: Take the J to Gates Avenue and walk from there.
Best Thrift Stores in Brooklyn – Greenpoint
19. Feng Sway
Feng Sway is a cute little plant store that also stocks a wide range of boutique vintage clothing and homewares.
Located just a stone’s throw from the river, the exterior is beautifully painted and beckons passersbys with the promise of stunning beauty within.
And it delivers since this sanctuary of calm is tastefully styled to resemble the gift shop of a sleek art gallery.
Plus, due to all the lush greenery and general serenity, Feng Sway has a very soothing vibe.
Therefore, it’s the perfect pitstop after sightseeing or hopping around some of the best coffee shops in Brooklyn.
But, perhaps the coolest thing about this Brooklyn thrift store is the wall of rugs. Yeah, they’re not exactly the most practical gift to take home with you but they are worthy of a look.
In terms of clothing, items veers on the boho side, with romantic maxi dresses, floral tea dresses, and twirly skirts on offer. The coat rack also throws out some dapper options too.
FYI, Feng Sway also carries a range of artsy trinkets like spiritual candles, crystals, and other ritual tools.
Yup, a true hidden gem in NYC with awesome staff to assist you with your purchase.
Address: 41 Norman Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222, United States
Hours: Open daily from 12:00 pm to 7:00 pm, with extended hours until 8:00 pm on Saturdays.
How to Get There: Take the G train to Nassau Avenue and walk from there.
20. Beacon’s Closet
Beacon’s Closet is a female-founded business with roots in Brooklyn. It’s also a place that has a strong commitment to sustainable and ethical practices.
As a result, it frequently well-ranked on various top 10 lists of the best vintage stores Brooklyn has to offer.
Now, the franchise operates three of the best thrift shops in Brooklyn across Greenpoint, Bushwick, and Park Slope respectively.
And, to the delight of every New Yorker, the team has since opened a branch in Manhattan.
However, the Greenpoint store in particular is swankily dressed in chandeliers, features exposed brickwork, and has ambient lighting that sets the tone for a lavish spree at a reasonable price point.
Plus, all clothing here is cherry-picked across second-hand donations, trade-ins, and consignment. Therefore, the atmosphere is top-notch and totally on-trend.
Oh, and they have a super legendary shoe collection. And no, that doesn’t just mean stilettos.
In fact, the range of footwear here spans everything from big brand pumps to sneakers to ankle boots, and hiking boots.
Address: 74 Guernsey St, Brooklyn, NY 11222, United States
Hours: Open daily from 11:00 am to 8:00 pm.
How to Get There: Take the G train to Nassau Avenue and walk from there.
21. Dream Fishing Tackle
Dream Fishing Tackle is so much more than Brooklyn’s number-one spot for replenishing bait supplies!
Although, yes, there is a tackle shop buried inside. However, Dream Fishing Tackle really does serve up a hodgepodge of vintage clothing, furniture, vinyl records, antiques, and collectibles.
Actually, the vinyls deserve a spotlight: since rumor has it that this place is home to one of the best supplies in Brooklyn. Yeah., the owner is a huge music fan and sources records from across all genres.
Just be aware that visiting one of the best thrift shops in Brooklyn is a bit of a treasure hunt.
But, it’s worth the effort purely to experience the kitschiness of this place and wander through the labyrinth of aisles – especially since you’ll find retro and modern pieces in equal measure
Also, have a peek at their Instagram feed since their latest items are proudly shared there to give you an idea of what they have to offer.
And, make no mistake, you won’t walk out of this tackle shop-cum-furniture depot-cum-vintage paradise without making a purchase (or four).
Address: 673 Manhattan Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222, United States
Hours: Open daily from 11:00 am to 8:00 pm, with reduced hours on Sunday from 12:00 pm to 7:00 pm.
How to Get There: Take the G train to Nassau Avenue and walk from there.
Best Thrift Stores in Brooklyn – Cobble Hill
22. Unearth Vintage
Hot off the press, Unearth Vintage is one of the newest Brooklyn thrift stores to land on the scene and cause a stir among New Yorkers.
Although, you might already be familiar with Arbor Vitae Vintage in Williamsburg.
Now, Unearth Vintage was conceived by the same family behind this other independent store. And their initial triumphs at NYC flea markets led to the founding of these two stores.
And, the result? A thoughtfully curated selection of true vintage and upcycled clothing. In fact, pieces date all the way from the 1940s to the early 2000s.
Plus, Unearth Village carries some truly luxurious fabrics, such as cashmere, silk, and leather.
So, the team here deserves a round of applause for their commitment to low prices that make this store super accessible.
Plus, this is one of the best thrift shops in Brooklyn that is neatly laid out, complete with friendly sales associates poised to lend a hand.
Also, it has to be said, that the mannequins are always sharply dressed and will inspire your very next super sleek ensemble.
Address: 159 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, United States
Hours: Open daily from 11:00 am to 7:00 pm.
How to Get There: Take the F train to Bergen Street station and walk from there.
23. Out Of The Closet
Out of the Closet is really one of the best thrift stores in Brooklyn. You know how you enter a thrift shop and everything just requires hours of digging through just to find something you like? Out of the Closet isn’t at all like that. Everything is neat and organized which makes shopping here such a joy.
From cutlery to clothes, the store has a wide selection of all kinds of knick knacks which are priced affordably. The staff are always super friendly and willing to help should you need anything. The best part is that the items really sell out fast so there is always something new the next time you visit.
Oh and did I mention that the proceeds from the store go to AIDS Healthcare Foundation? So shopping here does some good too! A win-win all around.
Address: 475 Atlantic Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217, United States
Hours: Mon-Sat: 10am – 7pm, Sundays the store closes early at 6pm.
How To Get There: Take the train to Atlantic Terminal and walk from there.
Best Thrift Stores In Brooklyn – Bay Ridge
24. Peace By Peace Thrift Store
Even thrift shopping has become expensive nowadays. Lol! That is unless you pick the right thrift stores in Brooklyn to head to. You really can’t go wrong with Peace By Peace Thrift store.
One of the reasons why people love this store is because of the numerous cute outfits that are on sale. The best part is that they are at reasonable prices.
If you get there early in the day, you will also find plenty of new items for discounted prices! The secondhand stuff isn’t too bad either. I highly doubt anyone goes home disappointed.
Oh and did I mention that they have homeware, board games, vintage items, books and even craft items?
Pro Tip: Look for their $1 bin on Saturdays. They always have some interesting items in there!
Address: 6931 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209, United States
Hours: Mon-Fri: 11am – 7pm, Sat: 10am – 8pm, Sun closed
How To Get There: Take the bus to Bay Ridge Avenue and walk from there.
Other Best Vintage Stores in Brooklyn
25. Consignment Brooklyn
Shopping in Boerum Hill Brooklyn and looking for high-quality merch like s 2008 Alexander McQueen leather shoulder bag?
If so then Consignment Brooklyn is one of the best thrift stores Brooklyn has to offer you.
After all, this amazing consignment store in Brooklyn was started by Eva Dayton who wanted to bring to designer threads to good old Atlantic Avenue.
Today, this is the best place to go for high-quality items that look like they’ve come right off the runway.
Yeah, every time I have visited everything has been in excellent condition. And you know the quality is exceptional since this store has been featured by the New York Times, Goop, and more.
Plus, I love that you can find more classic items from Chanel but can also buy sleeker, modern items from people like Alexander McQueen.
Address: 371 Atlantic Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11217
Hours: Open daily from 11:00 am to 6:00 pm.
How to Get There: Take the A/C/G train to Hoyt – Schermerhorn Station and walk from there.
Thrift Stores In Brooklyn FAQ
What Is The Thrifting Capital Of The USA?
New York City! Yes, NYC just happens to be the thrifting capital of the country. With the prices of everything outrageously high, it is really hard to keep a proper budget when living here. You still need stuff though so what can you do? Trust me… Head to one of the thrift stores and hunt there. Odds are you will find something new or barely used at a discounted rate.
The trick to getting a good buy is knowing where to shop though. Some of the thrift shops have amazing stuff, are neatly arranged and really make you feel like shopping there.
What Do People Buy Most At Thrift Stores?
People tend to buy clothes and shoes a lot at the thrift stores. This helps people avoid the high retail prices and simultaneously get good value for the money they spend. Contrary to belief, many of the thrift shops have barely used and even new items so if you visit often enough, you are likely to walk out with a great bargain.
The downside to thrift shopping however is that you don’t always get things in your own size.
Why Is Thrifting So Satisfying?
The prices around us in the city have been skyrocketing and heading out on a shopping trip means that you have to count your dollars. That’s not fun at all. Imagine going into a store and only being able to pick one item you want.
Thrifting on the other hand allows you to walk away with much more. It takes quite a bit of stress out of shopping and it is also a more environmentally friendly option!
⏰ In a hurry and wondering where to stay in Brooklyn? I highly recommend the Hampton Inn Manhattan-Seaport-Financial District. It is a midrange hotel with great views and all the luxury you could need! 🏨
Map of the Best Thrift Stores in Brooklyn
Additional Brooklyn Resources You’ll Love
There you have it! That just about wraps up this guide to the best thrift stores in Brooklyn.
Tell me, did your picks for the best thrift shops in Brooklyn make the list? If not then let me know below.
And if you found this post useful, be sure to join our email list before pinning this post now so that you can read it again later.
